US LNG Heel Inventory: Account for the Product Remaining With the Ship

Retained LNG needs a commercial treatment

When an LNG shipping proposal includes product remaining with the vessel, the commercial team should establish who owns that quantity, how it is valued, and when it is settled. Treating all retained product as an immediate loss can distort the voyage result. Treating it all as fully recoverable inventory can be equally misleading.

A publicly filed LNG bunker-vessel charter specifies separate provisions for heel purchases and redelivery settlement. It illustrates negotiated inventory treatment in one agreement, not a universal rule for LNG carriers. SEC-filed charter

For a US LNG cargo program, the useful question is therefore commercial: what financial position remains after the cargo movement or charter ends? The quantity required for safe operation belongs to qualified technical assessment. A financial model should use validated inputs and must not propose tank conditions, retention amounts, or operating instructions.

Distinguish location from ownership

The fact that LNG remains aboard a ship does not, by itself, identify its owner. Nor does payment of hire establish who pays for every quantity of LNG carried. Read the applicable sale and charter provisions together, with qualified review where needed, to establish the rights in the retained product.

ICC's introduction explains that Incoterms rules do not determine ownership transfer. The sale agreement must address title separately from the delivery terminology used in the transaction. ICC introduction

A commercial inventory schedule should identify the party with the relevant right, the measurement basis, the price basis for any transfer, and the event triggering settlement. These items can differ between delivery of the vessel, completion of a cargo voyage, and redelivery of the vessel. Combining them into a single generic heel allowance conceals those differences.

Where the charter continues into another cargo, retained inventory may remain part of the same commercial program. Where the charter ends, a settlement or other agreed treatment may be necessary. The financial boundary should match the decision being assessed rather than stopping automatically at the first discharge.

A fictional inventory reconciliation

Consider a fictional charterer that purchases LNG inventory worth $400,000 at the start of a short employment. At its end, the model identifies inventory worth $280,000 under an assumed agreed settlement basis. The remaining $120,000 represents the modeled reduction in inventory value over the employment. These amounts are invented and are not based on a physical operating prescription.

If the charterer receives the $280,000 settlement in full, its net inventory cash cost is $120,000, ignoring financing and any other expenses. Expensing the original $400,000 while also recording no closing inventory or settlement would overstate the modeled cost by $280,000.

If only $220,000 is payable under the actual settlement terms, the net cash cost is $180,000. The difference could arise from an agreed valuation basis or quantity treatment in this fictional case. The analyst should explain the reason rather than adjusting the number simply to make it equal to the initial purchase price.

If the $280,000 is payable later, the economic recovery and cash timing remain separate. A business may have a receivable while still needing funds for its next cargo. It should not treat the future settlement as immediately available cash or assume it can finance the next purchase without checking the collection date.

The inventory reconciliation also needs to avoid duplicate charges. If the modeled reduction has already been included in another cargo or fuel expense line, charging it again as a separate heel cost would overstate the total. Each quantity and financial effect should appear once within the selected accounting boundary.

Value the closing position on an appropriate basis

A retained quantity may be valued differently for a commercial forecast, an agreed sale, a contractual settlement, and financial reporting. Those purposes should not be mixed without explanation. An estimated market value does not establish what the counterparty must pay, while an agreed settlement price does not necessarily describe a separate resale opportunity.

When comparing offers, identify whether the closing value is fixed, formula-based, or still subject to agreement. If it depends on a future reference price, show the sensitivity. If it depends on a measured quantity, preserve that measurement uncertainty until the relevant evidence is available. Do not imply that a precise spreadsheet value makes the underlying amount certain.

The alternative employment matters too. Inventory that remains useful in an ongoing program may have a different commercial consequence from inventory at the end of a commitment. The analyst should assess the actual next use and rights available, rather than assuming either that all retained product is stranded or that it can always be monetized immediately.

Ask for the commercial boundary before comparing freight

A carrier proposal can look less expensive because an inventory purchase or settlement exposure sits outside the quoted hire or freight. Ask which party supplies the relevant product and how the financial position is resolved. This does not require disclosure of every operational detail; it requires clarity about the costs and rights the customer is accepting.

If proposals use different boundaries, normalize them before ranking. One may include a defined product settlement while another leaves the terms open. A provisional allowance can support early comparison, but the final decision should identify the unresolved term and the amount by which it could change the result.

Bring Zeaclub the LNG enquiry with the opening and closing inventory assumptions clearly separated from freight. That allows the commercial discussion to focus on the complete commitment, including any funding and settlement exposure. The aim is to account for retained LNG as the agreement actually treats it, while keeping technical decisions with the specialists responsible for the vessel and cargo.

Sources

Related articles