US LNG Pacific Deliveries: Include the Return Commitment in the Cargo Margin
The customer delivery may not end your shipping expense
A US LNG sale into a Pacific market should be evaluated through the end of the carrier commitment the seller actually bears. Discharge may complete the customer sale while leaving hire, repositioning, or another agreed obligation outstanding. Ignoring that remaining exposure can make a cargo appear more profitable than the complete transaction.
GasLog Partners' 2025 annual filing describes its time charters as including specified terms and redelivery provisions, with customers bearing substantially all voyage costs. This describes that company's arrangements, not every LNG charter. GasLog Partners filing
Start by identifying the actual end point in the proposal. It could be a destination-related completion event, an agreed redelivery location, or a continuing period of employment. The analyst should use the agreement's boundary rather than assume that every US-to-Pacific cargo creates the same round voyage.
Do not add a return cost automatically
A complete analysis can fail in either direction. A charterer might omit costs it remains obliged to pay after discharge. Alternatively, a buyer might add a hypothetical return leg to an all-in voyage quotation even though that expense is already reflected in the quoted freight and is not separately payable.
BIMCO publishes LNGVOY specifically as a voyage charter form. The existence of a voyage structure reinforces the need to inspect the proposed cost boundary rather than assume a time-based commitment. BIMCO LNGVOY scope
The relevant question is whose decision is being evaluated. An owner's internal voyage economics may include positioning that the cargo customer does not pay as a separate line. A charterer under a continuing arrangement may bear additional days directly. Keep those perspectives distinct so the comparison does not mix owner costs with customer obligations.
For a shipping enquiry, state whether the business seeks a price for one defined movement or employment capacity extending beyond that movement. That helps counterparties offer proposals on an intelligible basis and reduces the chance that two apparently comparable totals describe different commitments.
A fictional full-commitment calculation
Consider a fictional US Gulf Coast LNG sale with $2.4 million of contribution before the shipping expenses in this example. The modeled loaded movement costs $1.5 million. A calculation ending at customer discharge therefore shows $900,000 of remaining contribution.
Assume the actual carrier agreement also leaves the seller with $600,000 of incremental expense to complete a required return or redelivery commitment. The complete contribution is then $300,000. These are invented financial assumptions, not voyage estimates, carrier quotations, or route recommendations.
Suppose an alternative customer sale yields only $2.1 million before shipping, but its complete relevant shipping cost is $1.6 million. That alternative produces $500,000 of contribution and exceeds the first case by $200,000. Looking only at the first case's loaded movement would have reversed the ranking.
Now suppose the first case can secure permitted follow-on employment that earns $350,000 after every incremental expense and does not add an uncounted obligation. Its complete contribution rises to $650,000 and becomes $150,000 better than the alternative. The change is justified by the net additional employment, not by assigning an unsupported value to having a ship in the Pacific.
The follow-on opportunity must be compatible with the carrier's commitments and the cargo's timing. If it remains only a commercial lead, retain the $300,000 base case and show the $650,000 result separately. A scenario is useful precisely because it keeps the unconfirmed opportunity from becoming assumed income.
Check whether the return is genuinely incremental
If the vessel would incur a particular repositioning expense under either cargo choice, that common expense should not be presented as a unique penalty against one destination. Compare the alternatives from the same decision point. The total transaction accounts may still include the common expense, but it does not explain the difference between choices.
Conversely, a return requirement created by accepting one cargo is relevant even if payment occurs after the cargo sale has been recorded. The financial model should not stop at an accounting cutoff that excludes the expense generated by the decision. Match the cost horizon to the commercial obligation.
A continuing fleet program makes this more complex. The ship might have an agreed next loading in the United States, a possible third-party movement, or a contractual redelivery somewhere else. Those are different end states. Define the end state for each alternative and include the costs needed to reach it before ranking the options.
Test the effect on the next cargo
A longer complete cycle can affect the following US lifting even when the current delivery is profitable. If the same carrier is expected to perform the next movement, assess whether the schedule leaves a workable sequence. Qualified marine parties should validate the underlying timing and suitability assumptions.
The commercial consequence of a missed next lifting depends on the agreements. It could involve replacement shipping, an amended customer arrangement, or another negotiated response. Do not assign a generic penalty without identifying what the business actually owes and which alternative remains available.
The analysis should also avoid crediting both the full margin of the next cargo and a separate opportunity value for the same available vessel days. Those may represent the same economic benefit described twice. Use one consistent measure of the alternative employment being displaced or enabled.
Bring Zeaclub the US LNG delivery case with the carrier's complete employment boundary and any intended next cargo. That supports a comparison of proposals that reach the same commercial end point. A Pacific sale earns its margin across the obligations it creates, including the position in which it leaves the business after customer delivery is complete.
Sources
- GasLog Partners, 2025 annual filing. Company's charter and redelivery structure only, without current fleet availability claims; checked October 23, 2026.
- BIMCO, LNGVOY. Voyage-form scope only; checked October 23, 2026.
Related articles
- 0457: US LNG Carrier Charters: Buy the Employment Flexibility the Cargo Program Needs
- 0465: US LNG Charter Extensions: Compare the Option With an Executable Replacement
- 0341: US Kamsarmax Offers: Compare Voyage Contribution and Time Together


