US Trip Charter Proposals: Price the Delivery and Redelivery Boundaries

Follow the chartered employment beyond the cargo voyage

A trip-charter comparison should cover the period and locations for which the charterer would assume responsibility, not merely the sea passage between cargo ports. For a US cargo business, delivery before loading or redelivery after discharge can materially change the modeled hire and separately borne employment costs. A lower daily rate can be outweighed by a longer responsibility boundary.

The commercial task is to understand where the proposed employment begins and ends. Obtain the actual delivery and redelivery terms, then ask qualified operators to estimate the relevant time and cost. Do not assume that the cargo's departure and arrival points are automatically the same as the vessel's contractual handover points.

BIMCO's redelivery clause addresses final-voyage itinerary, notices and redelivery-related issues. BIMCO Redelivery Clause 2017.

That clause is a reference for the subject matter, not a statement that its wording applies to a proposed fixture. Review the actual terms and obtain advice on their effect. The commercial comparison should make the resulting assumptions visible rather than hide them within a single estimated trip length.

Break the employment into commercially relevant segments

Begin with any period between vessel delivery and cargo loading. The cargo team should understand whether it is paying for positioning, waiting or other agreed time before the vessel performs the principal movement. The estimate should identify the proposed location and the assumptions supporting the timing.

Next consider the cargo movement itself, including the planned loading, voyage and discharge sequence. Use consistent assumptions across candidates. If the vessels require different operational arrangements, obtain competent assessment and identify the commercial consequences without trying to establish suitability through a cost spreadsheet.

Then examine the period between cargo discharge and redelivery. A broader redelivery range may allow the charterer useful flexibility, while a specific location may require additional travel after the cargo has been delivered. Conversely, a location attractive to the owner may affect the proposal's overall commercial terms. Ask for the actual offer rather than assuming a standard price effect.

The purpose of segmenting the employment is not to count every hour with false precision. It is to expose the parts of the proposal that differ. A comparison that assigns the same duration to materially different delivery boundaries conceals the very issue the buyer needs to evaluate.

A hypothetical Gulf cargo with two delivery points

Consider a hypothetical US Gulf shipment for which Candidate A is delivered at the loading area and requires an assumed 20 payable days through redelivery. At $22,000 per day, hire is $440,000. Separately borne employment costs are estimated at $300,000, producing a modeled total of $740,000.

Candidate B is offered at $19,000 per day, but its earlier delivery point adds four payable positioning days to the same assumed 20-day cargo employment. Hire for 24 days is $456,000. If separately borne costs are $330,000, its modeled total is $786,000. B's lower daily rate accompanies a total that is $46,000 higher.

Now suppose B is offered on a revised basis with delivery at the loading area for $21,000 per day. On the hypothetical assumption of 20 days and $300,000 of other costs, its total becomes $720,000. That is $20,000 below A. The revised boundary changes the comparison more than the original daily-rate difference suggested.

These figures are fictional and do not predict a particular owner's pricing. They show why the cargo team can ask a useful commercial question about an alternative delivery basis. The owner may decline, quote differently or identify operational constraints. Evaluate the response received rather than entering the hypothetical alternative into the model as available capacity.

Assess the redelivery range as an option with limits

A choice of redelivery location can be useful when the final cargo destination remains flexible. Its value depends on whether the actual terms permit the option, when the decision must be made and what costs arise from exercising it. A broad geographic description should not be treated as unlimited freedom to redirect the employment.

Compare the option with the cargo business's realistic alternatives. If every likely shipment ends in the same location, paying for a wider range may add little value. If customer destinations can change, the range may reduce the need to renegotiate, but the team still needs to understand the operational and contractual conditions attached to it.

The final cargo should fit the intended employment. A promising additional movement can appear profitable when considered alone while creating a redelivery problem for the charter as a whole. Before relying on it, obtain an updated assessment of the full sequence and advice on whether the proposed orders fit the agreement.

Avoid treating a planning date as a contractual entitlement. Estimates help compare proposals, but the actual notice requirements, time limits and consequences of deviation require separate review. A model should identify uncertainty without pretending to resolve it through a favorable assumed completion date.

Include handover work in the practical comparison

BIMCO's delivery and redelivery survey clause concerns documenting vessel condition at the handovers. BIMCO survey clause.

For a proposed trip, ask the responsible parties what handover arrangements and associated commercial assumptions are required. The finance comparison should reflect the reviewed agreement, including relevant settlements and costs, rather than assume that completion of cargo discharge closes every remaining item.

Zeaclub's proposed trip-charter comparison should show the full responsibility boundary alongside the daily hire rate. Bring Zeaclub the intended cargo movement and the actual delivery and redelivery proposals to discuss the alternatives. A useful decision identifies what time and work each offer places with the charterer, then compares the resulting employment on a consistent commercial basis.

Sources

Related articles