US VLGC Charters: Compare Positioning Cost With the Headline Offer
Compare the period you must pay for
A US Gulf LPG cargo does not necessarily benefit from the lowest quoted VLGC daily hire. The charterer must consider where paid employment begins, how the vessel reaches the loading opportunity, and where the obligation ends. An attractive rate can become expensive when applied to a longer period or combined with additional voyage expenses.
Dorian LPG's fiscal 2026 annual report distinguishes voyage charters from time charters and describes different allocations of voyage expenses. Its disclosure illustrates why the commercial structure must be understood before comparing quoted amounts. Dorian LPG annual report
The actual agreement governs the proposed transaction. Do not assume that every offer follows the same cost allocation or delivery basis. Obtain the quotation's commercial scope and compare the total obligations needed to complete the export program.
Separate an open position from contractual delivery
A vessel's reported location is an input to the enquiry, not necessarily the place where the charterer starts paying hire. The owner may offer delivery elsewhere, include positioning in a voyage freight price, or seek an additional payment. Each structure can produce a different cost for the same US loading opportunity.
Similarly, an expected availability date is not automatically the agreed delivery date. The commercial proposal should identify the relevant period and conditions. If the cargo depends on a narrow loading opportunity, compare what happens when the vessel becomes available later than expected rather than treating the first date mentioned as certain.
BW LPG publicly describes both spot and period employment, as well as contracts of affreightment. That range of structures reinforces the need to specify the service being sought rather than request an undifferentiated VLGC price. BW LPG commercial fleet page
A trader needing one cargo moved may be comparing a voyage arrangement with a short period charter. A business with several supported shipments may value a longer employment period differently. The right comparison starts with the cargo program and then tests the offered structure against it.
Work through two complete time-charter proposals
Consider a fictional US Gulf cargo program. Offer A quotes an invented $45,000 daily hire and requires 40 paid days, including the positioning and redelivery periods assumed in the proposal. Its estimated charterer-paid voyage expenses are $800,000. Offer B quotes $50,000 daily hire but requires 33 paid days and $700,000 of equivalent voyage expenses.
Offer A costs $1.8 million in hire plus $800,000 in voyage expenses, totaling $2.6 million. Offer B costs $1.65 million in hire plus $700,000 in voyage expenses, totaling $2.35 million. The higher daily rate produces a $250,000 lower total under these assumptions.
This is not a market-rate comparison. It is a fictional example showing how the paid period changes the decision. The offers are assumed technically acceptable and capable of performing the same cargo program. Any real difference in service, timing, or contractual exposure would require additional analysis.
If Offer B instead requires five extra paid days, its hire rises by $250,000 and the total becomes $2.6 million before any additional voyage expenses. The apparent advantage disappears. That sensitivity identifies the importance of the duration estimate without pretending that the extra days are expected to occur.
A decision-maker should therefore see both the quoted rate and the evidence supporting the employment period. A precise daily number does not make an uncertain duration precise. The comparison needs a credible base case and clearly stated alternatives for the major timing changes.
Do not add positioning twice
For a voyage offer, determine whether the quoted freight already incorporates the owner's positioning economics. The charterer should not add a separate modeled ballast cost simply because the vessel begins elsewhere if the accepted freight covers the required transportation on that basis.
For a time-charter offer, identify the expenses and hire payable before loading and after discharge. A spreadsheet that begins at the loading port can omit part of the charterer's commitment. Conversely, a model that charges expenses belonging to the owner can overstate the charterer's cost.
Use the actual quotation to establish the boundary. If a separate payment is proposed for positioning, show it once and explain what it covers. If the parties are still negotiating that item, keep the unresolved amount visible rather than quietly treating it as zero.
A comparison between a voyage price and time-charter total should also include the same cargo requirement. A voyage offer for one shipment cannot be compared with a period charter that includes additional useful employment without recognizing that extra service. Equally, unused period days should not be credited as valuable merely because they remain available.
Treat redelivery value conservatively
A favorable redelivery location may help a charterer that has a confirmed next cargo or an agreed onward arrangement. Without that supporting opportunity, its value remains conditional. The business should distinguish a contractual right to use the vessel from a profitable use it has actually secured.
If follow-on employment is expected, prepare a separate complete case showing its revenue, expenses, and additional time. Then test whether the original US export remains acceptable without it. That prevents a weak first cargo from being justified by an unconfirmed return opportunity.
The redelivery obligation itself may also create a cost even when there is no follow-on cargo. Obtain qualified review of the agreed location, timing, and other commercial conditions. An internal routing assumption does not change what the charterer has promised to provide at the end of the employment.
Choose the offer with the stronger supported total
A practical comparison should summarize daily hire or freight, paid duration, separate voyage expenses, positioning payments, and the redelivery obligation. It should identify the few assumptions that can reverse the result. That gives the team a basis for negotiating a specific commercial term instead of simply asking for a lower headline rate.
Bring Zeaclub the US LPG program and the complete delivery and redelivery proposals being considered. The enquiry can then focus on the employment that actually serves the cargo. A competitive offer is one whose total cost and service fit the transaction, with the positioning assumptions visible before commitment.
Sources
- Dorian LPG, fiscal 2026 annual report. Charter structure and expense-allocation context only; checked October 23, 2026.
- BW LPG, VLGC fleet. Published employment structures only; checked October 23, 2026.
Related articles
- 0406: US Tanker Time Charters: Count the Cargo Work Before Buying the Days
- 0476: US Propane VLGC Cargoes: Test Parcel Size Against Destination Demand
- 0732: US Time Charter Comparisons: Add the Employment Costs to Hire


