US LNG Boil-Off Economics: Separate the Cargo Forecast From the Claim
An economic allowance is not a contractual recovery
A US LNG voyage model should distinguish the quantity expected to reach the customer from any compensation the charterer might recover if vessel performance differs from the contract. Those are separate calculations. A lower delivered quantity can affect the commercial result without establishing a valid claim against the owner.
The UK Defence Club's LNG guidance explains that cargo quantity and performance claims can overlap in this trade because LNG can also be used as fuel. Contractual treatment requires careful review. UK Defence Club guidance
The commercial task is to identify the assumptions supplied by qualified technical parties, translate them into the sale's quantity and price basis, and show how the outcome changes. This article does not prescribe boil-off rates, vessel settings, fuel choices, or operating procedures. Those decisions require the responsible vessel and technical teams.
Start with the unit that drives customer proceeds
A model needs to state what quantity the customer pays for and where that quantity is established under the sale. A preliminary loaded volume, estimated energy content, and final invoiced quantity cannot be treated as interchangeable simply because they all describe the same cargo.
OIML's LNG measurement discussion explains the relationship between volume, density, calorific value, and energy measurement. A volume comparison alone therefore does not establish the priced energy quantity. OIML measurement discussion
Ask the technical and measurement specialists for a consistent commercial input rather than performing an improvised conversion. The financial analyst should be able to explain whether the estimate concerns loaded energy, delivered energy, or another contractual measure. If the estimate is provisional, its uncertainty belongs in the margin sensitivity.
The value assigned to a quantity change also needs a basis. Customer revenue, replacement purchase cost, and an agreed contractual valuation can differ. The appropriate basis depends on the decision being modeled. Using whichever price produces the largest apparent loss is not a coherent method.
Compare the complete economic effect
Consider a fictional LNG sale in which the customer pays $12 per MMBtu of delivered energy. Under one modeled case, delivered energy is 2.95 million MMBtu and separately purchased fuel costs $800,000. Under another, delivered energy is 2.93 million MMBtu and separately purchased fuel costs $650,000. These are invented accounting scenarios, not technically validated operating alternatives.
The second case has 20,000 MMBtu less delivered energy, reducing modeled revenue by $240,000. It also has $150,000 less separately purchased fuel expense. With all other modeled amounts unchanged, its contribution is $90,000 lower. Looking only at the fuel bill would suggest a saving while overlooking the larger revenue reduction.
If the customer price were instead $6 per MMBtu under a separate fictional sale, the revenue difference would be $120,000. Against the same $150,000 expense difference, the second case would contribute $30,000 more. This sensitivity shows why cargo valuation affects the commercial result. It does not tell the crew which operating choice to make or establish that either scenario is physically available.
Do not add a further generic cargo-loss charge if the model already reduces customer revenue for the same quantity difference. That would count the economic effect twice unless the additional item represents a genuinely separate obligation, such as an independently payable contractual expense.
Model customer obligations separately from sale revenue
The example above assumes the customer pays for the modeled delivered quantity without another consequence. An actual agreement may require a different analysis. If the seller must supply a specified quantity, a shortfall could create a replacement requirement or another contractual response. The responsible advisers should identify the applicable obligation.
In that case, the model may need the cost of covering the customer rather than only lost revenue. Explain whether replacement restores the original sale quantity, whether it creates additional transport expense, and whether it can be obtained in time. Do not assume that a theoretical purchase price is an executable replacement opportunity.
A useful sensitivity changes one assumption at a time before testing a combined downside. That makes it possible to distinguish a quantity effect from a price effect and identify which uncertainty most threatens the expected contribution.
The original cargo purchase also matters. If its price is based on a different measurement point from the customer sale, the margin model should preserve both bases. Forcing the same quantity into both sides can conceal the exposure the trader is actually carrying between purchase and resale.
Keep the claim case out of the base cash forecast
A potential performance claim should be assessed under the actual charter with qualified support. The relevant evidence, contractual definitions, applicable period, and exclusions cannot be replaced by a comparison with a planning allowance. A budget is a management assumption; it is not automatically the owner's contractual undertaking.
For financial planning, show the voyage result before any unconfirmed recovery. A separate recovery scenario can then explain the claimed amount, its status, and the expected timing if payment is obtained. This prevents a disputed receivable from obscuring the cash needed to complete the customer obligation.
The same discipline applies when evaluating proposals before fixing. A performance undertaking may have commercial value, but it should not be credited as unconditional cash protection without examining its wording and practical enforceability. A lower estimate and a stronger recovery right are distinct attributes of an offer.
Bring Zeaclub an LNG shipping enquiry with clearly labeled quantity assumptions and the commercial basis on which the cargo will be bought and sold. That enables a more useful comparison of carrier proposals while leaving technical validation and contractual interpretation with the responsible specialists. The objective is a margin forecast that counts each economic effect once and makes any hoped-for recovery visible as a separate question.
Sources
- UK Defence Club, LNG Charterparties 2026. Interaction of cargo and performance claims only; checked October 23, 2026.
- OIML Bulletin, LNG custody-transfer measurement. Energy measurement context only; checked October 23, 2026.
Related articles
- 0450: Corpus Christi LNG Offers: Compare the Energy Quantity Behind the Cargo Price
- 0459: US LNG Heel Inventory: Account for the Product Remaining With the Ship
- 0892: US LNG Quantity Records: Reconcile Liquid Volume and Energy


