US Demurrage Discussions: Isolate the Issue Before Negotiating the Amount
Find out why the two calculations differ
A US cargo team receiving a charter demurrage claim should first identify the source of the disagreement. The parties may dispute an event, the treatment of a period, the rate applied or whether the claim meets the applicable requirements. Negotiating a percentage reduction before understanding the issue can obscure a straightforward correction or a material contractual question.
BIMCO's 2013 definitions address demurrage in relation to delay after laytime expires. BIMCO Laytime Definitions.
That context does not establish entitlement in a particular case. The actual charter, facts and relevant law require review by the responsible advisers. The commercial team's contribution is to organize the disagreement so that management understands what is established, what remains contested and what would change the proposed amount.
Separate factual disagreements from counting disagreements
A factual disagreement concerns what happened or when it happened. One record may show an operation ending earlier than another, or the parties may describe the reason for an interruption differently. The next step is to identify the supporting evidence and seek clarification from the people who can explain it.
A counting disagreement can exist even when the parties agree on the events. They may apply different assumptions about when time begins, which periods count or how an agreed allowance operates. The relevant provision and interpretation should be identified explicitly, with advisers assessing the legal question rather than the commercial team rewriting the chronology.
A rate disagreement is different again. Check the actual agreed basis, unit and any relevant variation. A daily rate applied to an hourly period requires consistent conversion. A mathematical error can be corrected without resolving every other issue in the claim, provided the correction is clearly distinguished from acceptance of entitlement.
Start the reconciliation from the same version of the claim. If the claimant has already revised an amount or withdrawn an item, comparing a response with the superseded calculation can make an apparent disagreement larger than the issue still being pursued.
These categories help the discussion progress. If the parties agree on a factual correction, record that narrow agreement and recalculate its effect. Do not assume it settles unrelated questions. Conversely, avoid holding up an obvious arithmetic correction merely because another part of the claim remains disputed.
A hypothetical claim with one contested period
Suppose a hypothetical claim uses 48 hours at an assumed rate of $24,000 per day, producing $48,000. The receiving team agrees that the stated events occurred but questions the treatment of a 12-hour period. For an isolated sensitivity test, excluding that period would leave 36 hours and a modeled amount of $36,000.
The difference attributable to that issue is $12,000. This does not mean $36,000 is automatically admitted or payable. Other questions may affect the claim, and the team's advisers must determine what can appropriately be acknowledged. The calculation simply locates the financial effect of the specific contested period.
Now suppose a separate factual correction reduces the original 48-hour period by six hours. The starting calculation becomes 42 hours, or $42,000 at the assumed rate. If the distinct 12-hour exclusion also applies in the scenario, the result becomes 30 hours, or $30,000. The team must confirm that the periods do not overlap before subtracting both.
This fictional example shows why issue-by-issue reconciliation is more informative than bargaining over a headline total. It also exposes double-counting. If two proposed deductions concern the same hours, adding them can create an apparent reduction unsupported by the actual chronology.
Review the claim process alongside the calculation
ITIC warns that demurrage claims can involve specific deadlines and designated communication addresses. ITIC time-barred claims introduction.
The team should identify the actual requirements with its advisers rather than rely on a standard number of days or a familiar email chain. The notice of a claim, supporting documents and subsequent communications may raise distinct questions under the agreement. A mathematically sound calculation does not answer every procedural issue.
Preserve what was sent and received, including attachments and any acknowledgment. If documentation is incomplete, identify the missing item and its significance for review. Do not assume that requesting clarification changes a deadline or waives a position. The appropriate wording and next steps should be determined by those responsible for the claim.
A commercial discussion can continue while an issue remains under review, but participants need clear authority. The person gathering evidence should know whether they are authorized only to ask questions or also to propose settlement terms. A useful internal briefing prevents an informal attempt to resolve confusion from being mistaken for a broader concession.
Assess settlement as a separate business decision
Once the issues are understood, management may need to consider whether a proposed settlement is commercially sensible. That decision should draw on qualified advice about the merits and process, together with the cost, time and business consequences of continued disagreement. It should not be presented as proof that either calculation was correct.
Explain the assumptions behind any recommendation. A settlement proposal may reflect uncertainty about evidence, the expense of further review or the value of resolving a particular dispute. Those reasons differ from correcting an agreed error, and the record should not confuse them.
Keep the proposed resolution's scope clear. Ask advisers what claims, periods or issues the settlement would address and what remains outside it. The commercial team should understand the practical result before it recommends a payment or acceptance, especially where several voyages or related claims are being discussed together.
Zeaclub's proposed claim-analysis workflow should help US cargo teams isolate the disagreement and prepare a coherent commercial briefing. Bring Zeaclub the competing calculations, relevant evidence and identified open questions to discuss the structure of the review. The aim is a focused negotiation supported by facts and appropriate advice, with arithmetic, entitlement and settlement judgment treated as distinct parts of the decision.
Sources
- BIMCO: Laytime Definitions 2013, checked October 24, 2026; demurrage definition context only.
- ITIC: time-barred claims introduction, checked October 24, 2026; deadline and address scope only.
Related articles
- 0743: US Laytime Estimates: State the Counting Assumptions Before the Result
- 0832: US Demurrage Disputes: Build the Event Record Before Arguing About Counted Time
- 0994: US Demurrage Evidence Checklist: Organize Events Without Deciding Rights


