US Demurrage Evidence Checklist: Organize Events Without Deciding Rights
Build a factual package before a claims conclusion
A demurrage evidence checklist should help a reviewer reconstruct the relevant events and connect them to the actual charter terms. It should not convert every hour of port time into a payable amount. The distinction between an event, its contractual treatment and its financial consequence is central to a useful review.
For a Louisiana bulk loading call, the commercial team may receive a statement of facts, notices, terminal records and correspondence from several participants. These documents can describe different aspects of the same period. The checklist should preserve their scope and any inconsistencies rather than selecting one convenient chronology and discarding the rest.
BIMCO and FONASBA recommend the published Standard Statement of Facts form. BIMCO Standard Statement of Facts.
A recognized form helps organize information, but the reviewer still needs to examine the actual completed record, supporting evidence and applicable agreement.
Separate event evidence from counting assumptions
Create an event register containing the stated event, timestamp, time zone, source and any qualification. Distinguish the time something occurred from the time it was reported or received. Those times may coincide, but they should not be assumed identical when the evidence says otherwise.
Keep a separate interpretation column for the proposed contractual treatment. That column can identify an agreed position, a party's contention or an unresolved question. It should not alter the factual event field. This design allows two reviewers to disagree about counting while still working from the same underlying chronology.
BIMCO's Laytime Definitions are intended for incorporation into charter parties. BIMCO Laytime Definitions.
The checklist therefore needs the actual agreed terms and amendments. A published definition should not be imported automatically just because the same expression appears in a message. The responsible contractual reviewer should determine the applicable wording and its consequences.
Identify the documents needed for the disputed period
Start with the charter and relevant amendments, then identify the records supporting the events that matter to the question under review. A notice-related issue may require the notice itself and evidence of its transmission or receipt. A stoppage-related issue may require records describing when the interruption began, ended and why it occurred.
Avoid collecting every available file without an index. Group evidence by event or issue and explain what each item supports. Preserve originals and identify translations or summaries as such. A summary can help a reviewer navigate the package, but it should not replace the underlying record when wording or timing is disputed.
Record missing evidence explicitly. If the start of an interruption is supported but its end is uncertain, state that gap. Do not fill it with the next convenient timestamp unless there is a reason to connect the two. An honest gap points to a targeted request; an invented interval can contaminate the entire calculation.
Work through a fictional timing disagreement
Assume a hypothetical event record shows an interval from 08:00 to 22:00 on the same day, a total of fourteen elapsed hours. Another record identifies a four-hour interruption within that interval. These times are invented and do not describe any actual call.
One proposed calculation counts all fourteen hours. Another treats the four-hour interruption differently and counts ten. The evidence worksheet should show the shared elapsed interval, the interruption's supporting records and the contractual question producing the four-hour difference. It should not label either calculation correct merely because its arithmetic is accurate.
If the applicable hypothetical daily rate for a later financial illustration were USD 24,000, four hours would represent USD 4,000 using a twenty-four-hour day. That figure quantifies the consequence of the disputed interpretation only. It does not establish that the period is demurrage, that the rate applies or that any amount is owed.
The next useful action is to identify the term and evidence needed to resolve the interruption's treatment. Arguing about the total before agreeing what the four hours represent can consume time without narrowing the issue.
Preserve conflicting records without amplifying confusion
Where sources disagree, place the competing statements next to each other and identify their origin. Ask whether they describe the same event, use the same time zone or record different stages of an operation. A conflict may be explained by scope rather than by an inaccurate document.
If a correction is issued, retain the earlier version and the explanation. Record who supplied the correction and whether other affected parties have reviewed it. Do not imply that a revised spreadsheet entry has amended an external document. The package should distinguish the original evidence from the analyst's reconciliation.
Keep factual descriptions neutral. An event record can state that an activity stopped and identify the reported reason without assigning fault. Liability language should come from the relevant reviewed position, not from an analyst's shorthand. This makes the evidence package more useful to both commercial and specialist reviewers.
Organize the handoff around unresolved questions
The final package should contain a concise chronology, the actual terms being considered, a document index and a list of unresolved issues. For each issue, state the competing treatment, the amount or time affected where calculable, and the next evidence or decision required. This lets the reviewer focus on what changes the outcome.
Track deadlines through the responsible claims process using the actual agreement and current advice. Do not assume that completing the evidence worksheet satisfies a notice or submission requirement. The worksheet can support a timely handoff, but the person responsible for the claim must confirm the required actions and timing.
Keep container detention and demurrage invoice reviews separate from this charterparty evidence package. Similar terminology can conceal different contracts and procedures. Identify the transaction type at the beginning so the review reaches the appropriate team and uses the correct source material.
Bring an anonymized chronology and the documents supporting one disputed interval to Zeaclub to discuss a proposed evidence-organizing workflow. The aim is to make US charter reviews more precise and efficient by separating facts, interpretations and arithmetic, while leaving entitlement and legal conclusions with the authorized decision-makers.
Sources
- BIMCO: Standard Statement of Facts, checked October 24, 2026; form identity and recommendation only.
- BIMCO: Laytime Definitions for Charter Parties, checked October 24, 2026; incorporation scope only, no automatic application assumed.
Related articles
- 0743: US Laytime Estimates: State the Counting Assumptions Before the Result
- 0832: US Demurrage Disputes: Build the Event Record Before Arguing About Counted Time
- 0742: US Notice of Readiness Records: Prepare the Facts for a Proper Review


