Assistance does not erase the master's duties

A tug master controls the assisting vessel. The tanker master remains responsible for the tanker and must exercise professional judgment for its safety, subject to lawful directions from competent authorities and the realities of the casualty.

Control of the combined movement must be agreed in operational language. Before connection, the parties should identify:

- who proposes course and speed; - who orders tension, slack or disconnection; - which VHF channel and backup method will be used; - the emergency stop and abort words; - who communicates with vessel traffic services; - what happens if propulsion or steering returns; and - which vessel reports changing risk to authorities.

“Proceed as agreed” is not a tow plan. Language, radio failure, smoke, blast damage and fatigue can turn an assumed command structure into conflicting helm and engine actions.

The tanker should provide accurate information about draft, displacement, trim, freeboard, cargo, damage, propulsion, steering, electrical power and tow connection. The assisting vessel should state its bollard-pull and manoeuvring limitations, connection proposal and operating envelope. Neither side should hide a limitation to accelerate acceptance.

Towage and salvage are not interchangeable

Ordinary towage usually concerns agreed movement of a vessel that is not in danger of the kind required for salvage. Salvage is voluntary assistance to maritime property in danger that contributes to a useful result. Exact characterization depends on facts and applicable law, not the label placed on a radio exchange.

A tanker disabled by hostile damage, drifting in constrained waters with cargo and pollution exposure may present the danger associated with salvage. Yet not every tug attendance automatically becomes a salvage service. The degree and immediacy of danger, voluntariness, existing contractual duties, success and governing law all matter.

The 1989 International Convention on Salvage retained the broad “no cure, no pay” approach to a salvage reward while adding incentives related to preventing or minimizing environmental damage. It also provides for special compensation in defined circumstances involving a vessel that threatens environmental damage. The final entitlement is a legal and evidential question.

Owners should involve hull and machinery, P&I and war-risk insurers early. Cargo interests and their insurers may also have exposure. Brokers can help locate assets, but should not make legal promises on behalf of an assured without authority.

Do not negotiate through the point of disaster

The shore team should try to record the basis of assistance, including any standard form, tariff, authority order or reservation of rights. But a master facing imminent grounding, collision, fire spread or pollution cannot safely wait while offices debate remuneration.

An urgent radio acceptance should be documented with time, participants and circumstances. Preserve the tug's offer, the ship's response and instructions from coastal or naval authorities. Silence about price does not make the service free. Nor does use of the word “tow” finally determine that salvage law cannot apply.

Commercial teams should split the work. One group secures immediate operational assistance. Another notifies insurers, obtains authority, evaluates contract terms and protects evidence. Forcing the master to mediate a multi-party legal negotiation from a damaged bridge is poor casualty management.

This does not mean accepting every demand. It means matching the speed of commercial decision-making to the physical danger.

A tow connection is a high-risk deck operation

SOLAS requires emergency towing arrangements at both ends of tankers of at least 20,000 deadweight tonnes. Their existence does not make connection routine.

Strike damage may have weakened fittings, interrupted lighting, blocked access or left unexploded ordnance. Fire and toxic vapour may restrict deck deployment. The tanker can be rolling or sheering while the assisting vessel works close aboard. Lines and gear under load create lethal snap-back zones.

The master should require a short, explicit job plan covering:

1. the selected strong point and its known condition; 2. messenger, pickup and towing gear sequence; 3. safe positions and escape routes; 4. personal protective equipment and communications; 5. maximum intended load or operational limit; 6. actions on line failure, fire or renewed attack; and 7. recovery or emergency release.

Only essential personnel should be exposed. A security threat can make a technically ideal connection location operationally unacceptable.

Record photographs or video from safe positions, the equipment used, times and observed loads if instruments permit. These records support later engineering and legal analysis, but should never distract a crew member from line safety.

Restored machinery changes the plan, not the history

If the tanker's engine restarts, the tow should not be disconnected by reflex. Confirm steering, control, electrical reliability and the cause of the original failure. Agree a controlled test and state who will order tow release.

The assisting vessel may remain needed as an escort, brake or contingency. A premature release can place both vessels in danger if propulsion fails again. Conversely, towing a vessel that can safely manoeuvre may create unnecessary connection risk and cost.

Log the sequence: first movement, test parameters, failures, communications, authority approvals and release. The fact that a vessel later proceeds under its own power does not erase the danger existing when assistance began or resolve whether a salvage award is due.

Destination requires coastal-state engagement

The tanker master may seek a place of refuge to stabilize the casualty and prevent greater harm. IMO Resolution A.1184(33) says the master or salvor should contact the appropriate Maritime Assistance Service, inform the coastal and flag States and provide incident information. The company should contact the competent coastal station and make itself available.

A coastal State must evaluate risk to its population, environment, port and infrastructure. It may request technical condition, cargo, pollution potential, weather, tow capability, security threat and financial-security information. Refuge is therefore a structured decision, not a unilateral choice of the nearest berth.

The tow plan needs alternatives if the preferred location is refused or becomes unsafe. Fuel endurance, tug availability, weather and crew fatigue should be included. In a conflict zone, further attack exposure and military restrictions also matter.

Owners and charterers should not publicly name a refuge before the coastal authority confirms it. Premature announcements can create political pressure, security risk and false expectations down the supply chain.

Build one evidence record for many disputes

A serious tow may later generate claims among owner, salvor, cargo interests, charterer and insurers. It can also support a marine casualty investigation or security inquiry.

Preserve:

- all distress, urgency and assistance communications; - automatic and manual position records; - authority directions; - tug and ship logs; - damage and pollution observations; - tow plans, risk assessments and connection records; - contractual offers and acceptances; - machinery restoration tests; and - voyage data recorder material.

Record facts separately from opinions. “Vessel drifting at 1.4 knots toward shoal water” is an observation if supported. “The service was definitely salvage” is a legal conclusion. “Projectile fired by X” is an allegation unless verified by a competent investigation.

War-risk involvement does not necessarily displace hull, P&I, cargo or charter-party issues. Policy wording, causation, sue-and-labour obligations, notice and deductibles require specialist review.

A practical scenario

A loaded product tanker loses power after an explosion and drifts across the edge of a traffic lane. A government-directed tug offers immediate assistance. The owner's salvage adviser is not yet on the conference call, and no price has been agreed.

The master warns traffic, shares accurate condition data, confirms the tug's intended connection and agrees operational command words. The shore team records that assistance is accepted because of immediate danger, notifies insurers and continues commercial discussions without delaying the connection. Coastal authorities evaluate a proposed sheltered location.

This is a hypothetical training scenario. It is not a claim about the tanker reported by UKMTO or a prediction of a future casualty.

Commercial conclusion

The best casualty protocol does not ask whether operations or contracts come first. It runs them in parallel under clear authority.

Masters need a ship-specific tow plan, tested communications and freedom to accept urgent safety assistance. Owners need insurer authority paths and a 24-hour salvage decision team. Charterers and cargo interests need disciplined updates, not control of the bridge. Salvors need honest condition data and an executable connection.

ZeaClub can maintain the common chronology, stakeholder notices, evidence index and action ownership. It cannot command the tow, grant refuge, determine a salvage award or replace advice on the applicable contract and law.

This article distinguishes verified source material from ZeaClub analysis, recommendations, forecasts and hypothetical scenarios.

Sources