Name the arrangement correctly

A naval escort, an authority-sequenced transit and an informal group of merchant ships are not interchangeable.

A naval escort involves military command and protection arrangements communicated by the competent force. Its scope, eligibility, rendezvous, communications and rules are defined by that authority. A commercial operator cannot create an escort by sailing near a warship. MARAD currently advises U.S.-flagged vessels to maintain a 30-nautical-mile standoff from U.S. military vessels, which directly contradicts any assumption that proximity is protective.

An authority-coordinated transit can sequence ships through a route or window without promising armed protection. Each master remains responsible for navigation. The plan may specify reporting, route, speed range and timing.

An informal group exists when operators agree to depart together or ships simply follow one another. It has no automatic legal status, traffic priority or common command. Calling it a convoy can mislead crews, charterers and insurers about the protection available.

The voyage file should state which arrangement actually exists and cite the issuing authority. If no competent authority has confirmed coordination, the assessment should describe independent ships in proximity.

Test whether the ships can remain compatible

Ships grouped at the entrance may differ sharply in size, draft, acceleration, stopping distance, turning circle and sustainable speed. A VLCC, product tanker, bulker, tug and dhow cannot be treated as interchangeable units.

The slowest vessel can compress traffic astern. A faster ship may attempt to overtake in constrained water. A machinery limitation can force the entire group to alter. Cross-currents, poor visibility and GNSS interference can magnify small speed errors.

COLREG obligations still apply. Every ship must maintain a proper lookout, proceed at a safe speed, assess collision risk and take appropriate action. Rule 13 requires an overtaking vessel to keep out of the way. A private agreement to hold formation does not displace those duties.

Before accepting any coordinated sequence, the operator should disclose genuine speed restrictions, draft, manoeuvring limits and technical defects through the authorised channel. The master should know the ship ahead, planned spacing and action if that ship slows or becomes disabled.

Spacing cannot be selected only to prevent another vessel from entering the line. It must allow for reaction, stopping, avoiding action and emergency craft. A formation that looks orderly on AIS can be unsafe if the ships cannot manoeuvre independently.

Do not assume numbers reduce attack risk

There is no general evidence that an informal cluster of merchant ships is safer from missiles, drones, projectiles or mines. More ships can provide more observers and relay capability, but they also create more potential casualties within one area.

A strike on the lead vessel may block the route and force following ships into emergency manoeuvres. Fire, debris or loss of propulsion can turn planned spacing into a collision problem. A strike on a ship in the middle can divide the group and complicate rescue access.

Grouping may also increase electronic and communications signatures. The May industry guidance warns that connected personal devices can leak geolocation and metadata. Multiple ships coordinating in unsecured chats or by repeated open radio calls can expose route and timing.

Risk assessment should distinguish verified facts from hypotheses. "Three ships transited without incident" does not prove the group deterred an attack. "A larger formation is harder to target" is a theory unless supported by the competent security authority.

Current JMIC guidance should drive the threat picture. Its 15 November update says deliberate attacks remain highly likely under current conditions and traffic remains below the 2025 baseline. A formation does not turn a severe environment into a moderate one.

Use one coordination channel

If a competent authority offers coordinated transit, operators should obtain the written or authenticated instructions and identify the operational contact. The plan needs rendezvous limits, route, sequence, speed, spacing, communications watch, abort points and response to a casualty.

VHF Channel 16 remains an emergency and calling channel, not a place for lengthy commercial formation management. Assigned working channels and reporting procedures should be used as directed. The bridge should avoid informal orders from an unidentified ship claiming to be convoy leader.

Each master must retain freedom to take collision-avoidance and safety action. A lead merchant ship cannot relieve following masters of their responsibilities. Any instruction that conflicts with immediate safety must be clarified and reported.

GNSS degradation demands independent position fixing. Ships should not follow the visual stern or AIS symbol of the vessel ahead as a substitute for knowing their own position. If the leading ship is spoofed off track, blind following can reproduce the error across the group.

The company security officer can maintain shore liaison while the bridge concentrates on the traffic picture. Charterers and brokers should not create a parallel coordination group that competes with the authority channel.

Plan for a ship leaving the sequence

Every coordinated movement needs a breakaway plan. A ship may suffer propulsion loss, steering failure, blackout, fire, medical emergency, suspicious approach or navigation uncertainty.

The affected master should report the problem promptly and state intentions. Other ships need enough distance to act without a chain reaction. The plan should identify safe holding or diversion areas where they exist, but it must not assume adjacent water is mine-cleared or suitable for anchoring.

The group should not automatically stop beside a casualty. SOLAS assistance duties and rescue coordination apply, but an uncoordinated cluster can create a second casualty or obstruct emergency units. The nearest capable ship may be asked to assist while others continue or hold at distance.

If one vessel misses the rendezvous, it should not accelerate into the sequence or cut across traffic. It needs fresh coordination. A slot is not a berth reservation that can be reclaimed regardless of the live picture.

After any breakaway, the remaining ships should revalidate spacing, route and window. The original plan may no longer be workable.

Allocate commercial responsibility realistically

A coordinated transit can reduce random merging and improve shared situational awareness, but it may add waiting time. Owners and charterers should model rendezvous delay, slowest-ship speed, suspension after an incident and loss of the assigned window.

The charter party determines the treatment of waiting, deviation and additional costs. No party should promise a convoy until the competent authority confirms that arrangement. Brokers should describe it as requested, offered, confirmed or cancelled, not simply available.

War-risk underwriters may want the planned route and coordination details. Their approval should not be represented as a safety guarantee. A change from independent transit to a coordinated movement, or the reverse, may require renewed disclosure.

Liability between ships remains governed by applicable law and facts. An informal agreement to sail together can create evidential questions about representations and communications without establishing a clear command structure. Owners should obtain legal advice before creating private operating rules.

A Zeaclub coordinated-transit board can record the authority, vessel constraints, sequence, spacing, validity and breakaway status. Access should be restricted, and the board should expire instructions automatically when timing or route changes.

The practical conclusion is narrow. Ships should participate in a current, authenticated authority-coordinated transit when their flag guidance, risk assessment, master and insurance conditions support it. They should not improvise a merchant convoy merely because several vessels are waiting. Orderly spacing can improve navigation. A name alone provides neither protection nor command.

This article distinguishes verified source material from ZeaClub analysis, recommendations, forecasts and hypothetical scenarios.

Sources