The accounting dispute

A time-chartered ship slows, waits, changes route, or burns more fuel during Gulf hostilities. Charterers may label the entire variance “underperformance” and deduct it from hire.

A valid speed-and-consumption claim requires the contractual warranty, qualifying conditions, reliable data, breach, causation, and the agreed loss calculation.

What is verified

Steamship Mutual's 2026 FAQ confirms that speed claims depend heavily on precise warranty and good-weather wording. BIMCO clauses preserve the master's safety obligations even when charterers can order speed or RPM.

Neither source creates a universal war exception.

Find the actual warranty

Start with the vessel description, recap, continuing-performance clause, maintenance duty, “about” allowances, “without guarantee” wording, laden and ballast figures, fuel grades, sea margin, and exclusions.

If no warranty exists, charterers cannot invent one from a routing report.

Delivery and continuing duties differ

Some warranties concern capability at delivery; others expressly continue throughout the charter. Even where the description is not continuing, owners may owe a separate maintenance duty.

Identify which promise is alleged to have been breached and when.

Good weather is contractual

The charter may define wind force, sea state, swell, current, draft, trim, and required duration. A Gulf passage with evasive routing, congestion, or security waiting may contain little qualifying weather.

Apply the agreed definition, not the analyst's preferred model.

A sufficient sample is needed

Steamship Mutual notes that some charters require a consecutive period, while otherwise the sample must be sufficient for the voyage. A short isolated window may not reliably prove capability.

State included and excluded periods transparently.

Weather and security are separate variables

Calm seas do not mean the ship was free to proceed at warranted speed. A naval instruction, mine threat, convoy speed, traffic separation, GNSS interference, or safe-distance requirement can constrain navigation despite good meteorological conditions.

Tag operational restrictions independently in the dataset.

Waiting is not steaming performance

Time at anchor, drifting, holding position, convoy assembly, security inspection, or port closure should not be treated as miles-at-sea performance unless the clause expressly does so.

Separate propulsion, maneuvering, and stationary consumption.

Route length is not speed loss

An alternative route can increase voyage duration while the vessel performs at warranted speed. Distance added by a valid safety decision is not automatically time lost through underperformance.

Compare actual speed over the relevant sailed legs, not original ETA alone.

Safe speed overrides commercial speed

BIMCO's CII and slow-steaming clauses preserve the master's obligations for vessel, crew, cargo, and environmental safety. The master may have to increase, reduce, or vary speed to avoid danger.

Record the safety reason and duration of each adjustment.

Charterer slow-steaming orders matter

Where charterers order reduced RPM or a specified arrival time under an applicable clause, compliance should not become an owner breach of due despatch. BIMCO nevertheless says warranted consumption at applicable speeds can remain relevant.

Written instructions prevent later disputes about who chose the setting.

Below-warranty speed may fall outside guarantee

BIMCO's explanatory notes say that where the vessel proceeds below a warranted speed at charterers' request, that operation falls outside the performance guarantee. The exact clause and ordered RPM remain decisive.

Do not extrapolate a low-load test into a service-speed claim.

Engines have safe operating limits

Charterers cannot require RPM outside existing safe operational limits or manufacturer recommendations under BIMCO's standard wording. Extended low load can affect fouling, lubrication, temperatures, and maintenance.

Owners should produce technical guidance rather than a bare refusal.

Hull fouling may have multiple causes

War waiting in warm Gulf waters can cause fouling and later performance loss. Liability may depend on charter length, trading orders, cleaning clauses, maintenance duties, and whether the warranty continues.

The hostilities explain the waiting but do not allocate fouling risk by themselves.

Fuel quality can break causation

Unsuitable charterer-supplied fuel may reduce speed or increase consumption. BIMCO's bunker-quality clause assigns resulting time, damage, and performance consequences to charterers where its test is met.

Preserve samples, seals, delivery notes, laboratory results, and engine records.

Logs and routing reports both need scrutiny

Owners' logs may contain manual errors; routing reports can apply different weather products, currents, or exclusions. Steamship Mutual notes that credibility and charter wording determine evidential weight.

Reconcile raw observations before debating methodology.

Current treatment must follow wording

Some warranties exclude adverse currents, while others require current correction or say nothing. Favorable and adverse effects should not be selectively applied.

Document the current source, resolution, and calculation.

Consumption needs the right denominator

Separate main-engine fuel, auxiliaries, boilers, inert-gas systems, cargo heating, tank cleaning, security equipment, and hotel load. War waiting can raise auxiliary consumption without showing propulsion inefficiency.

Allocate each stream to the charter promise and activity.

Off-hire is not the remedy label

A speed claim is generally a damages or hire-adjustment exercise under the performance wording. Calling it “off-hire” does not avoid proving an enumerated off-hire event and net loss of time.

Invoice and dispute categories should remain distinct.

A hypothetical rerouted tanker

Assume a tanker sails 300 additional miles under a documented war-risk decision, meeting warranted speed during qualifying weather but arriving a day later because of distance. There is no automatic speed breach.

This hypothetical does not decide extra-bunker allocation under the charter.

A stronger performance claim

Assume reliable engine and weather data show sustained qualifying conditions, no security restriction, no charterer slow-steaming order, and speed materially below the adjusted warranty with excess fuel.

That record supports a performance analysis even though the wider region remains at war.

Damages require causation

Calculate time and fuel loss attributable to proven breach after contractual allowances. Avoid charging owners for added route distance, excluded weather, safe-speed orders, waiting, cargo operations, or charterer-caused fuel problems.

Use the charter's extrapolation method where specified.

Evidence checklist

Keep recap, description, clauses, delivery survey, logs, noon reports, engine data, fuel records, samples, routing reports, raw weather, currents, position sources, threat instructions, convoy orders, route plans, RPM orders, maintenance, fouling inspections, cleaning, and calculations.

Preserve the original data and every transformation.

A joint data protocol

Owners and charterers can agree source hierarchy, time zones, noon boundaries, exclusions, good-weather criteria, current treatment, security tags, and review intervals before a dispute grows.

Independent experts should receive the same verified dataset.

Forecast: security tags will enter performance reports

Gulf routing platforms are likely to add structured fields for war-risk diversion, convoy speed, jamming, mine alerts, safe waiting, and insurer instructions. This is a forecast, not a current contractual standard.

Better tagging can stop safety time from being mistaken for machinery loss.

The ZeaClub view

War disruption complicates performance evidence but does not erase vessel warranties. The answer is disciplined segmentation, not a blanket excuse or blanket deduction.

Owners should prove safety constraints and maintain the ship. Charterers should test qualifying periods and causation. Brokers and claims teams should separate route, speed, waiting, weather, fuel, and off-hire. A precise dataset turns a geopolitical argument back into a contractual calculation.

This article distinguishes verified source material from ZeaClub analysis, recommendations, forecasts and hypothetical scenarios.

Sources