The dual problem

Hormuz disruption can strand vessels away from planned bunker ports, restrict supplier access, inflate prices, and leave only non-compliant or technically unsuitable fuel available. The operator then faces regulation and contract at the same time.

A Fuel Oil Non-Availability Report addresses one regulatory process. It does not decide who breached the charter or who pays.

What is verified

Steamship Mutual reported 2026 Gulf fuel-availability concerns following the de facto Hormuz closure. IMO guidance explains the MARPOL Annex VI non-availability process and required evidence.

The regional shortage context does not prove non-availability for a particular ship.

A FONAR is not an exemption

IMO states expressly that a FONAR is not a waiver or exemption. The destination port authority scrutinizes the evidence and decides what action is appropriate.

Owners and charterers should never describe filing as guaranteed permission to burn non-compliant fuel.

Best efforts need proof

The IMO expects evidence of attempts to obtain compliant fuel according to the voyage plan and from alternative sources. Repeated or poorly supported claims can trigger further scrutiny.

Keep quotations, refusals, specifications, quantities, delivery windows, and supplier communications.

Notify early

IMO guidance says the master or company should notify the flag Administration and destination authority as soon as non-availability is known, preferably before leaving the port where fuel cannot be obtained.

Late filing weakens both regulatory credibility and the contractual record.

Charter responsibility comes first

Determine who must procure and pay for bunkers, which grades and specifications are promised, where supply is contemplated, and whether charterers control the itinerary. Time-charter forms commonly allocate supply to charterers but retain owner duties for machinery and compliance.

Read bespoke clauses before assigning shortage risk.

Price is not the same as absence

Compliant fuel may be available at a high price, a different berth, another supplier, or a nearby port. IMO expects operators to consider logistical conditions and alternative sources.

A commercially unattractive quotation does not necessarily establish non-availability.

Safety can limit alternatives

A technically available fuel may be unsafe for tanks, purification, heating, injection, stability, compatibility, or engine operation. The vessel need not accept a stem that creates an unreasonable safety risk merely to avoid delay.

Document technical review and manufacturer guidance.

Different compliant grades may be expected

IMO says ships should prepare, as far as reasonably practicable, to use compliant fuels with different viscosity or sulphur content, potentially requiring different lubricants or treatment.

Operational inflexibility can undermine a best-efforts claim if adaptation was reasonably feasible.

Voyage planning must include endurance

Calculate remaining onboard quantities, segregated grades, unpumpable fuel, safety margin, security diversion, waiting, weather, auxiliary demand, cargo heating, inert gas, and next reliable bunker opportunity.

An optimistic straight-line estimate is inadequate during war.

War rerouting changes the equation

Owners may lawfully alter route or wait under a war clause, increasing consumption beyond the original plan. Whether charterers fund the extra fuel depends on hire status, orders, war-risk wording, and causation.

The FONAR does not allocate that commercial consequence.

Minimum non-compliant supply is constrained

Steamship Mutual's 2026 analysis notes that authorities may allow only the minimum non-compliant fuel necessary to reach the next port where compliant fuel can be sourced. Operators should not treat an emergency stem as a trading inventory.

Verify the actual authority direction and conditions.

Bunker quality remains contractual

Scarcity does not remove specification, merchantability, compatibility, stability, or statutory requirements. If charterers supply unsuitable fuel, BIMCO's quality clause allocates resulting damage, performance loss, time, and expense under its terms.

Take representative samples and preserve custody records.

Sampling is evidence infrastructure

IMO emphasizes bunker delivery notes and representative samples. During constrained supply, record manifold sampling, seals, labels, witnesses, retained quantities, laboratory methods, and fuel changeover.

One compromised sample can undermine a major claim.

Non-lien protection still matters

Emergency purchasing from unfamiliar suppliers can expose the vessel to payment and lien disputes. BIMCO's non-lien clause requires charterers to notify sellers that supply is for charterers' account and to provide seller and payment information.

Urgency should not erase basic counterparty checks.

Owners can reject deficient arrangements

Under BIMCO's non-lien wording, the master may refuse supply where charterers fail specified information requirements, with hire and expenses allocated by the clause. Technical or sanctions concerns may create additional grounds.

Any refusal should state the evidence needed to cure the defect.

Redelivery quantity is a separate promise

A vessel approaching redelivery may lack the agreed fuel quantities or grades because Gulf stems were unavailable. That creates an accounting and contractual issue distinct from environmental enforcement.

Calculate physical shortfall, replacement value, location, grade, and any permitted tolerance.

A detour solely to meet redelivery is risky

Owners should distinguish fuel needed for safe voyage compliance from fuel purchased to restore a contractual redelivery balance. A special detour can cause time, bill, and deviation disputes.

Agree location, quantity, time, cost, and hire treatment in writing.

Off-hire is not automatic

A bunker shortage does not itself stop hire. Charterers must identify an applicable off-hire event and net loss of time. Owners must consider whether their own failure to plan, maintain systems, or comply caused the delay.

Keep off-hire analysis separate from bunker reimbursement.

Force majeure needs prevention

A clause may list war, government action, or supply disruption, but the affected party still must satisfy its causal test, notice, mitigation, and foreseeability requirements. Higher cost alone may be insufficient.

Analyze the exact obligation said to be prevented.

A hypothetical case

Assume charterers were to supply VLSFO at a planned Gulf port that closes. They obtain written refusals from alternatives, owners verify compatibility limits, authorities receive a timely FONAR, and minimum emergency fuel is authorized.

This hypothetical supports regulatory good faith but does not by itself settle hire or damages.

A weaker case

Assume the ship ignores several available compliant suppliers because prices are high, sails without adequate reserve, and files only after port-state inspection. A FONAR label will not cure the evidential gaps.

Contract and regulatory exposure can arise together.

Evidence checklist

Preserve charter clauses, voyage plan, tank soundings, consumption forecast, supplier list, quotations, refusals, specifications, port constraints, threat changes, technical assessments, flag and port notices, FONAR, authorizations, BDNs, samples, lab results, non-lien notices, invoices, hire statements, and redelivery survey.

Keep all timestamps and quantities consistent.

Forecast: bunker clauses will gain crisis ladders

Future Gulf fixtures are likely to specify alternative ports, maximum detour, price thresholds, emergency grade hierarchy, compatibility review, sanctions screening, authority filings, time allocation, and redelivery settlement. This is a forecast, not a current industry standard.

An agreed ladder can replace an improvised midnight decision.

A fuel-crisis decision sheet

Track required grade, quantity, reserve, supplier, price, delivery window, port access, sanctions, safety, compatibility, alternatives, route effect, charter duty, notice, authority, FONAR evidence, hire, costs, lien, sampling, next compliant port, and redelivery balance.

Update consumption and availability at every operational change.

The ZeaClub view

Fuel non-availability is a fact to prove, not a form to invoke. FONAR can support regulatory consideration when best efforts fail, but it neither grants immunity nor reallocates charter risk.

Owners and charterers should integrate endurance, safe-fuel engineering, supplier evidence, notices, and redelivery accounting. The commercially strongest response secures lawful propulsion first, then resolves time and money from the contract rather than asking an environmental report to do both jobs.

This article distinguishes verified source material from ZeaClub analysis, recommendations, forecasts and hypothetical scenarios.

Sources