US Voyage Speed Assumptions: Compare the Whole Commercial Cost

Compare approved scenarios, not a speed chosen by a spreadsheet

A US Gulf chartering team can compare the commercial consequences of alternative voyage assumptions, but a spreadsheet does not establish a safe or permissible vessel speed. Operational personnel and the applicable agreements define the scenarios available for review. Within that boundary, the analyst can examine how fuel, elapsed time and delivery needs affect the economics.

BIMCO's CII voyage clause describes speed adjustments within agreed parameters rather than an unrestricted choice. BIMCO CII voyage clause.

That clause-specific context illustrates why a commercial estimate should not assume unilateral freedom to change the voyage. The actual charter and carriage arrangements require their own review. This article does not recommend operating speeds, determine regulatory compliance or provide navigational instructions.

The useful commercial question is narrower: if the responsible parties identify two acceptable scenarios, what costs and benefits differ between them? Answering it requires more than comparing fuel totals. A longer passage can change vessel time, customer consequences and the ability to perform later commitments.

Use a common route and a stated cost boundary

Ensure the scenarios cover the same modeled movement unless a route difference is intentional and separately explained. A speed comparison can otherwise conceal a distance change. Keep the assumed distance, passage duration and other relevant inputs visible so the reader can understand what produced the result.

Fuel assumptions should come from appropriate vessel-specific information and responsible review. Do not apply a generic consumption relationship as if it were a validated performance model for the vessel. The commercial worksheet can accept approved estimates without pretending to generate the underlying technical answer.

Separate costs that vary with time from costs that remain unchanged in the comparison. A daily vessel cost may continue while the passage lasts longer, while some port expenses may be identical under both scenarios. Showing those categories makes it easier to understand why lower fuel expenditure may or may not reduce total cost.

Also state whether the model values the vessel's next available day. If later employment is uncertain, show the assumption rather than treating every saved hour as a saleable service. Time can have commercial value without that value being known precisely at the moment of comparison.

A hypothetical passage compares fuel savings with additional days

Assume two fictional, operationally reviewed scenarios for a 3,600-nautical-mile passage. The faster scenario uses an assumed average of 15 knots, giving 240 sailing hours or ten days. The slower scenario uses 12.5 knots, giving 288 hours or twelve days. These numbers are arithmetic inputs only, not recommendations for any real vessel.

Suppose the responsible technical estimate assigns 300 tonnes of consumption to the faster scenario and 240 tonnes to the slower one. At an invented $600-per-tonne cost, the modeled fuel totals are $180,000 and $144,000. The slower scenario saves $36,000 in fuel under these assumptions.

Now add an assumed $20,000 daily vessel cost over the passage. The faster scenario has $200,000 of time cost and a combined total of $380,000. The slower scenario has $240,000 of time cost and a combined total of $384,000. The fuel saving is outweighed by the additional two days, leaving the slower scenario $4,000 more expensive within this boundary.

At an alternative hypothetical daily cost of $15,000, the totals become $330,000 and $324,000, making the slower scenario $6,000 cheaper. The break-even daily cost is $18,000 because two additional days then cost exactly the $36,000 fuel saving. A different consumption estimate or a different passage duration would change that threshold.

Connect arrival time to the customer's actual requirement

Veson's VMS bunker documentation includes a speed-comparison function alongside vessel consumption-profile information. Veson VMS bunker documentation.

A comparison tool can calculate consequences from inputs, but the business still needs to establish what the resulting arrival time means. An earlier arrival may not advance cargo handling if the required services are unavailable. A later arrival may be acceptable for one customer and costly for another. Those consequences should be supported by the relevant commercial and operational information.

In the fictional example, a two-day longer passage should not automatically be assigned two days of customer loss. First determine whether it changes the delivery milestone that matters. If both scenarios meet the same required receiving window, that particular loss may be absent. If one misses a reviewed commitment, include the appropriate consequence rather than an arbitrary daily penalty.

Likewise, do not claim an environmental result solely from the financial comparison. An emissions assessment has its own inputs and boundary. Lower modeled expenditure can arise from a price change, and fuel quantity alone may not settle a broader environmental claim. Keep any such assessment separate and appropriately supported.

The analyst should also consider uncertainty in arrival. A scenario that appears feasible only under a narrow favorable assumption deserves a sensitivity test. The purpose is to understand the decision's dependence on timing, not to present the most optimistic estimate as a commitment.

Report the tradeoff and the conditions of the conclusion

A concise decision note should identify the approved scenarios, the source of their consumption estimates, the time-cost assumption and any customer or follow-on consequence. State which input would reverse the ranking. That makes the result useful to both commercial and operational reviewers.

When the voyage plan changes, update the comparison rather than carrying forward the original conclusion. A revised port window, distance or employment opportunity can alter the commercial value of time. Preserve the earlier assumptions so the team can explain the change instead of treating the new result as inconsistent arithmetic.

Zeaclub's proposed voyage-economics review can help US teams discuss these approved alternatives with a transparent cost boundary. Bring the responsible parties' scenarios, customer timing needs and commercial assumptions to Zeaclub. The aim is to understand the tradeoff while leaving navigation, technical suitability and contractual authority with the people responsible for them.

Sources

Related articles