Editorial note

This article provides general information, not legal, regulatory or financial advice. Requirements depend on the applicable contract, authority and jurisdiction.

Nautical charts and navigation instruments laid out for study

A short tender clause can change the obligation being priced

The Shipowners' Club's October 28 guidance explains that its standard mutual cover addresses legal wreck-removal liabilities, while broader contractual obligations may require contractual liability cover. Its advice depends on the precise wording and the applicable insurance arrangement. Club guidance.

For a US offshore operator or project buyer, the commercial question is what extra promise the tender asks a contractor to make. A sentence that appears to address the same event as an existing policy can still describe a different obligation. The price should reflect the promise being negotiated, rather than the familiarity of the subject heading.

The legal background must also be kept distinct. IMO describes the Nairobi Convention as a framework for hazardous wrecks and financial security. Its application requires jurisdictional and factual review. IMO overview.

Neither source establishes the coverage of a specific vessel, offshore project or war-related event. This analysis concerns how to compare proposed contractual responsibilities before committing to them. It does not prescribe removal methods or decide who would be legally liable after a casualty.

Describe the requested outcome before negotiating the premium

A tender may use a broad phrase such as restore the project area. The project buyer may believe that phrase expresses a straightforward commercial objective. The contractor may read it as an obligation whose scope is unclear. Before discussing price, both sides need to establish what the proposed agreement is intended to accomplish.

Questions include whose property is involved, which work area the promise concerns and how the parties would establish that the obligation had been fulfilled. The answers matter because an undefined result can create uncertainty about both cost and completion. Resolving the wording is not merely an insurance administration exercise; it is part of defining the service being bought.

The insurer's review should then address that actual wording. Asking whether wreck removal is generally covered is less useful than presenting the proposed clause and the commercial activity. A response about one agreed version should not be assumed to apply to a later, broader revision.

A project buyer should also understand why the contractor asks for clarification. It may be trying to obtain a reliable price and an insurance response, rather than refusing to accept responsibility. A precise scope can make competing bids easier to compare because the bidders are pricing the same promise.

Compare bids on an equivalent obligation

Consider a fictional offshore service tender. Bid A quotes $900,000 for the defined service and includes a narrowly described contractual responsibility. Bid B quotes $960,000 and expressly includes an additional requested undertaking. These are invented figures and do not describe actual insurance premiums or removal costs.

If the buyer compares only the headline totals, Bid A appears $60,000 cheaper. Suppose its contractor then offers to accept the additional undertaking for $75,000, subject to a satisfactory contractual and insurance review. On the revised commercial scope, Bid A becomes $975,000, which is $15,000 more than Bid B.

That calculation does not establish that Bid B is preferable. The buyer still needs to compare the exact promises, exclusions, conditions and evidence supporting both offers. The point is that a lower initial price may simply reflect less responsibility being offered.

Now suppose the buyer can narrow the additional undertaking to a defined requirement that both bidders can price more accurately. Bid A offers the clarified scope for $935,000, while Bid B revises to $945,000. The difference is now $10,000, and the buyer has a more meaningful commercial comparison. The hypothetical revision illustrates the value of resolving scope before treating a premium difference as a market signal.

No expected loss or insurance recovery has been calculated. Those would require information not supplied in this example. The analysis concerns bid comparability and the cost of different promises, not the probability or financial severity of a casualty.

Distinguish an insurance response from the contractor's residual exposure

A contractor may be willing to accept a proposed obligation even if some exposure remains outside the insurance arrangement it can obtain. That is a commercial decision requiring an explicit understanding of the residual risk. It should not occur accidentally because the contract and insurance review used different descriptions.

Likewise, a project buyer should not assume that an insured contractor transfers every possible cost to an insurer. The buyer's own position depends on the agreement and the applicable cover. A certificate or a general description of insurance is not a substitute for the review needed to answer a specific question about an unusual undertaking.

The timing of the review matters. If the parties agree a broad clause and only later seek confirmation of the insurance response, the contractor may face a choice between accepting an unplanned exposure and reopening a concluded commercial discussion. Addressing the wording during the bid stage gives both sides more room to make a deliberate decision.

The parties should also identify what happens when the project scope changes. An additional work area or a new responsibility may justify a fresh review. Treating the original price and insurance discussion as permanently applicable can conceal a material change in the service.

Make the final comparison readable to the decision-maker

A useful recommendation states the agreed service, the additional undertaking and the unresolved condition in plain language. It should explain why the preferred bid is commercially stronger on that scope. A long list of policy names is less useful if the decision-maker cannot see which obligation each arrangement is intended to support.

The recommendation should avoid presenting an insurer's general guidance as a guarantee for the proposed work. The October publication is a reason to ask a more precise question. The answer must come from the actual contractual and insurance review, with the relevant parties' responses preserved.

A proposed Zeaclub workflow could keep each bid's responsibility description alongside the version reviewed by the insurer and advisers. Bring that comparison into the next offshore tender discussion: which promise is included, what it adds to the price and what remains with the contracting party. That makes the insurance question part of the commercial decision before the obligation is accepted.

Sources