State command roles before the casualty

The master-pilot exchange should establish the intended passage, ship condition, propulsion, steering, tug use, communications and local hazards. In a high-threat Gulf transit it should also cover:

- current security level and relevant warnings; - areas where evasive action is constrained; - emergency anchor or abort locations; - VTS and naval communication channels; - tug capability and release arrangements; - navigation interference; - safe waiting or refuge options; and - the pilot's emergency transfer expectations.

The pilot should know the ship's manoeuvring limits and equipment defects. The master should know the pilot's plan and local constraints. The officer of the watch must continue an independent check.

IMO's pilotage framework under Resolution A.960(23) promotes effective coordination between pilots and ship personnel. A pilot's presence is a safety resource, not a substitute for bridge-team management.

Record material changes to the plan. A route agreed before a new threat warning may no longer be appropriate.

The master retains ultimate responsibility

The master remains responsible for the safe conduct of the ship and should intervene when necessary. The pilot provides advice and may conduct communications or give manoeuvring recommendations within the established bridge arrangement.

In an attack, the master may need to prioritize security, fire, flooding or casualty response over the normal pilotage sequence. The pilot should state the local consequences of proposed action, including shoal water, traffic, port restrictions and tug limits.

No one should debate titles while danger develops. Use closed-loop orders:

1. state the intended action; 2. repeat and confirm it; 3. execute through the proper control; 4. verify ship response; and 5. report deviation.

If the master takes direct conning, say so clearly. If the pilot continues to advise or communicate, define that role. The officer of the watch should plot and challenge unsafe divergence.

A port or chartering message cannot displace the master's safety authority.

Build one common emergency picture

The first bridge assessment should cover threat, position, traffic, manoeuvring, ship damage and pilotage constraints.

The pilot can help answer:

- What water is immediately available? - Which traffic or tugs are nearby? - Can the ship stop, turn or anchor without blocking the channel? - Which authority controls movement? - What local emergency berth or refuge may be considered? - Which radio report will produce the fastest response?

The ship team should provide propulsion, steering, fire, flooding, personnel and cargo status. State confidence and limits.

Use one bridge display or written board for actions and constraints. Avoid separate conversations between pilot and VTS, master and company, and officer and tugs that produce conflicting manoeuvres.

If language or radio congestion creates ambiguity, slow the communication, not the safety action. Confirm orders with standard marine vocabulary where appropriate.

The pilot is part of the muster

Account for the pilot as a person onboard. Provide protective equipment, shelter, lifejacket and emergency briefing appropriate to the casualty. Include the pilot in abandonment and rescue planning.

Do not assume the pilot knows the ship's escape routes, breathing-apparatus locations or alternate bridge. Assign a crew liaison if the bridge team disperses.

The pilot can also be injured, shocked or fatigued. The master should monitor fitness and request relief or medical support when necessary. Local expertise is valuable only if the person can safely perform.

Protect personal and medical information. Public updates should not name an injured pilot before authority and family procedures are followed.

If the pilot becomes incapacitated, notify VTS and the pilotage authority immediately and clarify whether the vessel can continue, anchor or receive a replacement.

Emergency manoeuvres still require navigation discipline

A security recommendation to increase speed or alter course must be checked against channel width, under-keel clearance, squat, bend geometry, traffic and tug position. The pilot is essential to this local assessment.

The master should not accept an evasive manoeuvre that the ship cannot execute safely, and the pilot should not dismiss a verified threat because it falls outside the normal passage plan.

Confirm steering mode, engine response and tug orders. A tug made fast can restrict a turn or be endangered by rapid acceleration. A released tug may become an additional moving target or rescue asset.

Navigation lights, sound signals and VTS reporting remain relevant. If the ship loses control, report its actual status promptly.

Satellite-navigation interference increases the value of pilot knowledge, but local familiarity does not replace radar, visual bearings, echo sounder and independent position verification.

Do not attempt an unsafe pilot transfer

Attack does not automatically require the pilot to disembark. A pilot boat transfer exposes people on ladders and small craft, often near the ship's side where damage, fire, oil or hostile small craft may be present.

Before transfer, assess:

- ship speed, list and freeboard; - wind, sea and visibility; - condition of the transfer arrangement; - damage, fire and pollution near the station; - pilot boat capability and security; - traffic and route; and - whether the pilot remains necessary for safe navigation.

SOLAS Regulation V/23 governs pilot transfer arrangements. IMO adopted revised requirements and performance standards in 2025 that are expected to enter into force in 2028. The applicable current requirements and flag instructions still govern a 2026 operation.

Every person involved shares responsibility for safe transfer practice, but the master should not permit an arrangement known to be unsafe.

If transfer cannot occur, keep the pilot protected aboard and coordinate an alternative port, station or relief.

Port authorities need actionable information

The pilot may be the fastest link to VTS and port control, but the master should know what has been reported. Messages should include position, manoeuvring status, damage, fire, injuries, dangerous cargo, pollution threat and assistance required.

Separate a legal movement instruction from advice or information. Repeat critical instructions on the bridge and record them.

The port may close a channel, direct traffic, allocate tugs or identify a place to stabilize. It also needs to protect terminals, pilots and responders from further attack.

Do not conceal damage to preserve berth access. A damaged ship entering confined port waters can create a larger casualty. Conversely, do not assume the nearest anchorage is safe without security and navigational assessment.

UKMTO security reporting can proceed in parallel, but it does not replace port and rescue communications.

Shoreside parties should support one bridge team

The company should nominate one emergency coordinator and avoid calling the pilot separately from the master. The pilotage authority and port should coordinate through the operational bridge channels.

Charterers need delay, cargo and destination effects but should not issue navigation instructions through an agent. Insurers and legal teams can obtain the chronology after immediate control is established.

Preserve the master-pilot exchange, passage plan, VDR, VTS audio, tug communications, engine and helm orders, damage reports and any change of conning.

If accounts differ later, keep each person's contemporaneous observations. Do not pressure the pilot or crew into a joint narrative.

The casualty investigation may need local traffic-system data in addition to ship records.

A controlled scenario

A loaded tanker with a pilot aboard is outbound in a dredged channel when an explosion damages steering control. A tug remains made fast, and a security warning reports another unidentified contact.

The master clearly takes direct conning while the pilot advises on channel geometry and contacts VTS. The officer verifies position and rudder response. The tug receives one confirmed order. The pilot remains aboard because transfer near the damaged side would be unsafe. Port control clears traffic and identifies a controlled anchoring option.

This is a hypothetical training scenario, not a report of a specific attack or forecast.

Commercial conclusion

An attack does not make the pilot the commander, and it does not make local knowledge optional. The safest bridge integrates the master's authority, pilot's expertise and officer's independent monitoring.

Owners and pilotage authorities should add security contingencies to master-pilot exchanges. Masters need clear intervention language. Pilots need the ship's actual capabilities and protection onboard. Charterers and agents must stay outside the manoeuvring chain.

ZeaClub can record roles, passage changes, authority instructions, tug orders and evidence. It cannot con the ship, certify a transfer arrangement or replace the master, pilot and competent port authority.

This article distinguishes verified source material from ZeaClub analysis, recommendations, forecasts and hypothetical scenarios.

Sources