Freeze the voyage data recorder promptly

The voyage data recorder is a central source because it can capture the ship's position, movement, physical status, command and control before and after an incident. SOLAS Chapter V requires VDR or simplified VDR carriage for defined passenger and cargo ships.

The master and trained officers should follow the maker's and ship's procedures to preserve or save the relevant recording. Do this as soon as emergency duties permit. Do not experiment with controls or remove a protected capsule without authority and technical competence.

Record:

- the incident time and time standard; - when the save or preservation action was attempted; - who performed it; - alarms or error messages; - whether power was interrupted; - the system model and recording media; and - any subsequent restart, repair or download.

A successful button press does not prove that every expected data channel was recording. Bridge audio, radar, AIS, position, gyro, alarms and engine inputs may have separate faults. Preserve annual test and maintenance records so investigators can assess coverage.

If a technical download is made, retain the original media or forensic image, record its hash where competent personnel can do so, and avoid repeated conversions. Playback software and ship-specific configuration may be necessary to interpret proprietary data.

Preserve original logs before creating a narrative

Secure the deck, engine, cargo, radio, security, medical and oil-record materials relevant to the event. Keep originals in their normal form. If electronic systems are at risk, make controlled exports or images and document the process.

Do not rewrite rough entries into a cleaner chronology. Corrections should remain traceable under normal logkeeping practice. A late entry should be labelled with the time it was made and the event time it describes.

Collect the records that explain system condition before the incident:

- planned maintenance and recent defects; - bridge and engine standing orders; - voyage and security risk assessments; - drills and equipment tests; - watch and rest records; - cargo and bunker plans; - navigation warnings and route changes; and - company and authority communications.

The purpose is not to overwhelm investigators with files. It is to preserve the context needed to distinguish a sudden hostile event from an equipment condition, operational response or reporting gap.

Keep media in its original form

Crew photographs and video can show damage, smoke, debris, craft, sky, sea condition and equipment displays. They can also expose people, security arrangements, coordinates and commercially sensitive information.

Ask crew not to edit, crop, annotate, filter or post original files. Preserve the original device or make a controlled copy retaining metadata. Assign each item a unique reference and record who captured it, when, where, and whether the device clock was accurate.

A screenshot forwarded through a messaging application may lose metadata and quality. Keep it as a communication record, but seek the original file. Do not claim that metadata proves the depicted event if the device time or location settings were unreliable.

Never direct a seafarer to return to a damaged area for a better photograph. Remote imagery, class attendance or later inspection can fill gaps. Safety outranks evidential completeness.

Establish a simple chain of custody

Chain of custody is a record of possession and handling. It helps show that evidence remained identifiable and was not silently altered.

For each physical item or digital collection, record:

1. a unique identifier and description; 2. where and when it was found or obtained; 3. who collected it; 4. packaging, storage or copy method; 5. every transfer, with date, time and recipient; and 6. any opening, testing, alteration or damage.

Do not place suspected ordnance, projectile fragments or unknown devices in an office evidence bag. Establish an exclusion area, notify competent authorities and follow explosive-ordnance advice. Touching or moving an object can injure people, destroy forensic value and violate local law.

Damaged machinery should remain available for inspection where operationally possible. If it must be moved to stop fire, flooding or pollution, photograph or sketch its original position and record why the change was necessary.

Separate observation from attribution

Witness notes should capture what a person directly saw, heard or did. “Two loud impacts approximately 20 seconds apart” is an observation. “Two missiles fired by State X” combines classification and attribution that the witness may not be able to verify.

Use clear categories:

- verified shipboard fact; - individual observation; - third-party report; - technical assessment; - allegation by a named authority; and - hypothesis requiring investigation.

UKMTO may report that a vessel was struck by an unknown projectile. That wording is evidence of the report and maritime warning, not final proof of weapon type or perpetrator.

Do not merge multiple witness accounts into a consensus before investigators interview them. Shared discussion can unintentionally harmonize memories. Preserve each person's first notes and the information available to them at that time.

Interview people humanely

Medical care, rest and contact with families come before a corporate debrief. Shock, fatigue, injury and language can affect recall. A rushed group call designed to produce a market statement is not a substitute for a competent interview.

The IMO safety-investigation framework seeks to identify contributing factors and prevent recurrence, not to apportion blame. Other investigations may have different legal purposes. Seafarers should be told who is interviewing them, for what process, how the record will be used, and what representation or support is available under applicable law and agreements.

Use open questions before specific prompts. Record the interview method, participants, language, interpreter and breaks. Distinguish a contemporaneous witness note from a later signed statement.

Protect medical and personal data. Circulate it only to parties with a legitimate need.

Control digital communications

Preserve emails, chat exports, voice notes, satellite-phone records, SSAS messages, UKMTO reports and communications with coastal or naval authorities. Include attachments and timestamps, not only selected screenshots.

Corporate platforms can apply retention limits. Issue a documented preservation instruction to relevant shoreside custodians, including operations, technical, security, chartering and senior management. Suspend routine deletion for the defined matter where lawful and technically possible.

Do not create new uncontrolled channels. One verified incident log should reference original messages without replacing them. Restrict access according to security, privacy and legal needs.

Cyber teams should preserve system logs if navigation or communication interference is suspected. Collection methods must avoid changing the affected systems or exposing the ship to additional cyber risk.

Many investigations can follow one event

A deliberate attack may fall outside the technical definition of a marine casualty used for some IMO statistics, yet the response can still involve a marine safety investigation into navigation, fire, abandonment or pollution consequences. Security and criminal authorities may also investigate the intentional act.

The flag State normally has a central safety-investigation role, while coastal States and substantially interested States may participate under the Casualty Investigation Code. Class, insurers and commercial parties conduct separate reviews.

The company should appoint one evidence coordinator and maintain an access log. This avoids conflicting requests to the crew and untracked copying. It does not allow the company to withhold material lawfully required by competent authorities.

Legal privilege differs by jurisdiction. Marking a routine operational email “privileged” does not create protection by itself. Obtain qualified advice without contaminating the factual record.

A controlled scenario

A tanker suffers two nighttime impacts. The bridge loses one radar and later restores power. Crew photograph damage and exchange images in a group chat. A suspected fragment lies near the accommodation.

The master preserves VDR data when emergency duties allow, secures original logs and asks crew to retain unedited files. The fragment is isolated and reported, not handled. The company preserves shore communications and appoints a single evidence coordinator. Separate witness notes are taken after medical care and rest.

This is a hypothetical training scenario, not a report of a specific vessel or an attribution of attack.

Commercial conclusion

Good evidence preservation protects safety learning and commercial fairness. It can resolve whether machinery failed before or after impact, when warnings were received, what orders were given, and which losses followed the casualty.

Owners should give ships a short preservation checklist and VDR training. Charterers, brokers and insurers should request evidence through the incident coordinator rather than directly burdening survivors. Investigators need originals, provenance and uncertainty, not a polished corporate story.

ZeaClub can index records, custody transfers, requests and verified facts. It cannot conduct a forensic download, decide privilege, attribute an attack or replace competent authorities and investigators.

This article distinguishes verified source material from ZeaClub analysis, recommendations, forecasts and hypothetical scenarios.

Sources