Delay and off-hire are different questions
A tanker may lose weeks waiting inside or outside the Gulf while fully crewed, mechanically sound, and ready to sail when a safe window appears. Charterers suffer lost commercial time, but that fact alone does not suspend hire.
Off-hire depends on the clause, the event, loss of time, required service, and causation.
Hire normally runs continuously
Time charterers purchase the vessel's service for a period and generally bear ordinary employment delay unless they establish an off-hire event or another remedy. Gard's guidance describes continuing hire where the vessel remains efficient and at charterers' disposal.
The burden and exact test depend on wording and governing law.
Read the precise event list
Standard forms and riders may refer to deficiency of crew, stores, machinery breakdown, damage, detention by arrest, drydocking, deviation, or “any other cause” with or without “whatsoever.” War waiting may not fit a named event.
Do not reason from the label “off-hire clause” without parsing its actual language.
Identify the service immediately required
The relevant service might be sailing through Hormuz, waiting for orders, remaining at anchorage, discharging, or complying with a convoy schedule. A vessel can be physically capable yet unable to perform the immediate service because of a qualifying event.
The counterfactual timeline should ask what the ship would have done absent that event.
Physical closure is not essential
Gard's 2026 FAQ notes that whether the strait is “officially” closed does not itself resolve off-hire. Danger can exist without a legal closure; conversely, an official restriction may still need to fit the contractual event and causation test.
Evidence should distinguish closure, advice, threat assessment, and owner choice.
A reasonable safety decision is not machinery failure
If the master waits because mines or attacks make transit unsafe, the vessel may remain fully efficient. That can favor continuing hire under a conventional clause, especially where charterers' employment brought the ship into the area.
A bespoke war-delay or navigation-refusal provision could allocate the period differently.
CONWARTIME addresses some hire consequences
CONWARTIME 2025 states that the vessel remains on hire during specified compliance events, without prejudice to other off-hire provisions. The wording avoids treating every convoy, official direction, insurer requirement, alternative call, or crew-change liberty as automatic off-hire.
Other periods still require the full charter analysis.
An owner breach creates another route
Even if charterers cannot satisfy the off-hire clause, they may allege damages or set-off for owner breach. That requires identifying the obligation, breach, causation, remoteness, and loss rather than rebranding every breach allegation as off-hire.
Wrongful refusal of safe orders could therefore be analyzed differently from justified waiting.
Charterers' orders can reverse the logic
Where the vessel waits because charterers ordered it into an exposed Gulf trade, owners may invoke the war clause or an employment indemnity. Gard's earlier conflict guidance says a fully efficient ship detained by the consequences of chartered employment can remain on hire absent contrary wording.
The order history must be preserved from fixture onward.
Deviation has its own wording
Some forms expressly place the vessel off-hire during deviation contrary to charterers' orders, while a war clause may authorize rerouting or compliance with compulsory directions and state that conduct is due performance.
The parties must reconcile the deviation clause, war clause, employment orders, and route actually sailed.
GNSS interference may not fit standard wording
Electronic jamming or spoofing can slow or stop safe navigation without physically damaging equipment. Gard observes that many standard off-hire clauses do not expressly address such third-party cyber interference.
If the bridge cannot safely perform the service, wording and causation still determine whether time is deducted.
Crew status can change the result
War anxiety alone is not necessarily a crew deficiency. Refusal to sail, repatriation, injury, detention, or minimum-safe-manning problems may create a different factual event. Owners' due diligence and employment obligations can then become relevant.
Record actual availability and decisions rather than characterizing the entire crew as “unable.”
Concurrent causes require a timeline
Suppose mine danger causes waiting, while the vessel also repairs a pump. Charterers may argue that a qualifying machinery event independently caused time loss. Owners may argue the ship would have waited anyway.
Build hour-by-hour counterfactuals showing readiness, repair completion, orders, safety windows, and actual movement.
Notice and protest protect positions
Charterers should identify the relied-on clause, event, start time, service lost, and hire calculation promptly. Owners should reject unsupported deductions, provide readiness evidence, and reserve indemnity and damages rights.
Unexplained netting from the next hire payment can escalate a factual dispute into a payment-default dispute.
Payment under protest can preserve operations
Parties may agree escrow, security, or payment under reservation while continuing the charter. The legal effect depends on wording and correspondence, so reservations must be explicit.
Keeping the vessel supplied and crew paid should not be jeopardized by an avoidable accounting standoff.
Hypothetical waiting tanker
Assume a tanker completes discharge at Ras Laffan but waits twelve days because verified mine reports and insurer route conditions prevent a safe exit. Engines, crew, certificates, and stores remain ready; charterers order departure whenever safe.
This is hypothetical. A standard off-hire result would depend on the precise clause and causal facts, not the twelve-day loss alone.
Voyage charters use another framework
Off-hire is a time-charter concept. Under a voyage charter, delay may concern laytime, demurrage, detention, deviation, freight adjustment, exceptions, or damages. Gard notes that detention generally requires a breach, while cargo-operation time follows its own clauses.
Do not import a time-charter deduction into a voyage fixture.
Forecast: war-delay riders will become more detailed
BIMCO's 2026 consultation identifies off-hire, delay, redelivery, and trapped vessels as tested areas. Parties are likely to negotiate specific Gulf waiting events, evidence, grace periods, and cost splits. This is a forecast, not an adopted standard clause.
Precision can reduce disputes but may shift significant exposure unexpectedly.
An off-hire evidence grid
Record clause text, alleged event, start and end, immediate service, vessel capability, master decision, charterer order, official notice, insurer condition, crew status, machinery status, route, actual delay, counterfactual delay, concurrent cause, notice, hire deducted, and reservation.
Update it daily while the vessel waits.
The ZeaClub view
Off-hire is a contractual exception to continuous hire, not a fairness switch activated by expensive delay. A dangerous Hormuz transit can strand a commercially idle but fully efficient vessel.
Owners should prove readiness and justified safety decisions. Charterers should test the actual event and lost service against the clause rather than deducting by instinct. The best analysis follows the vessel's timeline minute by minute and the charter's words line by line.
This article distinguishes verified source material from ZeaClub analysis, recommendations, forecasts and hypothetical scenarios.
Sources
- BIMCO, CONWARTIME 2025Accessed 2026-11-19
- Gard, Middle East conflict FAQsAccessed 2026-11-19
- Gard, War in Ukraine: contractual obligationsAccessed 2026-11-19
- BIMCO, Gulf contractual gaps consultationAccessed 2026-11-19
- Gard, Risky business: geopolitical security threatsAccessed 2026-11-19