The urgent request
A laden vessel refuses a dangerous Gulf discharge port and charterers nominate a safer port outside the bill's destination. They offer a letter of indemnity and demand immediate compliance.
The LOI may provide recourse against its issuer. It does not itself amend the carrier's contract with the lawful bill holder.
What is verified
Gard's 2026 Gulf FAQ specifically addresses alternative discharge, cargo consent, liberty clauses, on-forwarding cost, and International Group LOI Form B. BIMCO's VOYWAR 2025 provides alternative-discharge machinery and a charterer indemnity.
Those mechanisms must be matched to the actual charter and bill.
Identify the governing carriage contract
Determine who is carrier, which bill set remains outstanding, whether it has been switched, who holds it, and what charter terms are validly incorporated. A charterer's order does not necessarily bind a third-party bill holder.
Review both the face and reverse of every operative bill.
War clauses can add a route
VOYWAR 2025 allows owners, in defined circumstances and on reasonable judgment, to refuse dangerous performance and seek or select alternative discharge. It also addresses adjusted freight and documents supporting the calculation.
Confirm the clause was incorporated into the relevant contract.
Charter due fulfilment is not universal
VOYWAR says compliant action is due fulfilment of the charterparty and contracts of carriage. Whether that language binds a bill holder can depend on incorporation, governing law, and mandatory rules.
Do not assume a head-charter clause travels automatically.
Consent reduces uncertainty
Gard recommends seeking consent from bill holders, cargo owners, shippers, and receivers where possible. Consent should identify port, custody, freight, costs, condition survey, onward carriage, documents, and reservation of unrelated rights.
An agent's informal approval may not bind the entitled party.
Form B has a specific function
International Group LOI Form B concerns delivery at a port other than that stated in the bill. Form C addresses both a different port and delivery without production of the original bill.
Using the wrong form can leave a central risk outside the promise.
An LOI is credit, not insurance
The carrier substitutes the indemnifier's promise for part of its legal and insurance protection. Steamship Mutual emphasizes that an LOI does not reinstate Club cover as of right.
Assess issuer credit, assets, jurisdiction, security, and authority before relying on paper.
Bank participation can matter
International Group forms BB and CC contemplate a bank joining the undertaking. A reputable bank commitment may strengthen recovery where cargo value or detention security is substantial.
Verify signatures, authority, conditions, governing law, and service details.
Unlawful conduct remains dangerous
An indemnity should not persuade a carrier to participate in fraud, sanctions evasion, false documentation, or delivery known to defeat the entitled holder. Gard warns that insurance may not respond to unauthorized alternative discharge and deviation.
Escalate suspicious requests rather than pricing them.
Discharge and delivery are different
Cargo can be physically discharged into secure custody without being legally delivered to the receiver. The LOI, terminal receipts, warehouse terms, customs status, and release instructions should distinguish those events.
Ambiguity can create a misdelivery claim even when the vessel has sailed.
Originals still control delivery
Under English-law practice, delivery without production of the original bill carries serious misdelivery exposure. Steamship Mutual notes that liability to the lawful holder can be difficult to defend.
If originals are absent, follow the separate LOI and identity-verification process.
P&I cover needs direct confirmation
Gard's Rule 34 guidance warns that liability from discharge at an unauthorized place may fall outside ordinary cargo cover. Deviation can also threaten defenses under the Hague or Hague-Visby regime.
Contact the Club before committing, not after discharge begins.
Alternative-port safety still matters
A port selected to avoid Hormuz may have its own missile, drone, mine, berth, draft, congestion, labor, or sanctions risks. The contractual alternative must satisfy the applicable safety standard.
Complete a fresh threat and port assessment.
Cargo condition needs a baseline
Conduct joint or protective surveys, record temperatures and seals, sample where appropriate, photograph holds or tanks, and preserve discharge records. Gard recommends outturn evidence when war redirects cargo.
This separates transit damage from later storage or onward-carriage loss.
Onward carriage needs terms
If cargo must reach the original Gulf destination by feeder, truck, pipeline, or storage transfer, define who contracts, bears risk, pays, insures, handles customs, and controls documents.
An LOI for ship discharge may not cover the entire logistics chain.
Freight adjustment needs proof
VOYWAR 2025 contemplates adjusting freight for estimated time and expenses incurred or saved when discharge occurs elsewhere. Owners should show distance, time, bunkers, port charges, premiums, and savings.
Charterers should audit net cost without delaying undisputed sums.
A hypothetical tanker
Assume a tanker bill names Jebel Ali, the bill incorporates a suitable war liberty, and a verified threat makes entry dangerous. All bill holders consent to discharge at Fujairah, originals are presented, and onward costs are agreed.
This hypothetical has a stronger legal and operational foundation than a bare charterer's email.
A higher-risk hypothetical
Assume the bill names a Gulf port, no effective liberty is incorporated, the lawful holder objects, originals are absent, and an undercapitalized trader offers a homemade LOI. Discharging elsewhere could create uninsured cargo and misdelivery exposure.
Commercial urgency does not cure those defects.
Sanctions screening continues
Screen the alternative port, terminal, storage operator, receiver, agent, bank, trucker, feeder vessel, and indemnifier. A safer nautical location can introduce prohibited commercial participants.
Record list and ownership checks at the decision time.
Notices should separate legal bases
Issue the war-risk notice under the charter, request cargo consent under the bill, document the proposed variation, and request the appropriate LOI as distinct steps. Combining everything into one message obscures who owes what.
Preserve all reservations and response deadlines.
Evidence checklist
Keep charter, bill sets, incorporation wording, title chain, voyage and war notices, threat assessment, consent, LOI, bank undertaking, Club advice, sanctions checks, port assessment, surveys, freight calculation, terminal receipts, original-bill presentation, release authority, and onward-carriage terms.
Reconcile quantities and condition at every custody handoff.
Forecast: crisis discharge protocols will be pre-agreed
Future Gulf fixtures are likely to specify alternative-port ranges, automatic cargo-consent workflows, approved LOI forms, minimum bank standards, onward-carriage allocation, digital document channels, and sanctions gates. This is a forecast, not an existing universal rule.
Pre-agreement can save days when a laden ship must leave danger.
The ZeaClub view
An LOI transfers financial exposure; it does not magically create a delivery right. The carrier must first understand the charter liberty, bill contract, title holder, mandatory law, insurance, and proposed custody chain.
Owners, charterers, traders, and insurers should treat alternative discharge as a documented mini-voyage: lawful authority, safe port, correct documents, secured indemnity, cargo evidence, and funded onward delivery. Anything less converts a security decision into a cargo claim.
This article distinguishes verified source material from ZeaClub analysis, recommendations, forecasts and hypothetical scenarios.
Sources
- Gard, Middle East conflict: frequently asked questionsAccessed 2026-11-19
- BIMCO, VOYWAR 2025Accessed 2026-11-19
- Gard, Rule 34: Cargo liabilityAccessed 2026-11-19
- Steamship Mutual, International Group standard LOI circularAccessed 2026-11-19
- Steamship Mutual, Rival cargo claims and the carrier's dilemmaAccessed 2026-11-19